Skip to main content
Go to the dating site of The Bulletin
  • Log in or register

Search form

Home
  • Features
  • Events
  • TV & Film
  • Guides
  • Q&A
  • Real estate
  • Classifieds
  • Jobs
Home
Home>Q&A>Contesting a traffic offence?

Current issue Subscribe Request a welcome pack

Q&A - Contesting a traffic offence?

Category

All categories

Advice & Coaching
Animal
Arts
Beauty
Belgium
Children
Culture
Education
Food & Drinks
Health
Holiday
Property
Shopping
Sport
Transport
Wellness
Work
Login to post a question
11
Answers
Advice & Coaching
traffic ticket, tribunal, penalty, courts, Legal
Contesting a traffic offence?
pkompfner -
Feb 22, 2012

Has anyone experience of contesting a minor traffic offence (passing a red light in a traffic jam) at the tribunal? Is a lawyer needed, and is the fine greater than if you pay the "no-contest" fine?

Login to answer this question

I have no experience in contesting a fine, but I have recently studied the Belgian road code again and I must warn you that passing a red light is not considered a minor traffic offence here. It is actually a third degree offence in a scale of four:

http://www.polfed-fedpol.be/verkeer/verkeer_amendes_fr.php

Unless you are 100% positive that you did NOT pass a red light, I would regrain from contesting the fine.

PreviouslyAnon
Feb 22, 2012

"contesting a minor traffic offence (passing a red light in a traffic jam)"

Oh dear!!! This is considered as a crime in Belgium.

Why do you believe you are required to go to Court??

Topgun
Feb 22, 2012

X, wrong again. Only fourth degree offences are "crimes" strictly speaking. You certainly do not risk prison for burning a red light -- unless you also commit a fourth degree offence or another criminal offence when doing so.

PreviouslyAnon
Feb 22, 2012

Or you dare to contest it....

Topgun
Feb 22, 2012

Nope. Contesting a fine is neither a "dare" not a criminal offence, it's a basic civil right.

PreviouslyAnon
Feb 22, 2012

Consider the cost , a lawyer will cost more than the fine anyway .

Emille B.
Feb 22, 2012

a non-specialized lawyer speakin french or Dutch (only) costs 150€/h minimum.

Unless you do have an excellent "protection juridique" insurance which accepts to give you a lawyer for free...

Topgun
Feb 22, 2012

Considering the fine will be Eur 150 (according to http://www.polfed-fedpol.be/verkeer/verkeer_ame)I frankly
do not think it will make much sense to contest this -
unless you have hard evidence supporting your case....

Karl K.
Feb 22, 2012

I'd just pay the fine if you can, we have friend who was hit my a car coming the wrong way out of a one way street on his right and lost the case because as a non belgian driver he was told he did not under stand the Priority right rule! We also knew someone who due to a mix up at work did not get his speeding fine notice in time to pay and the result was a very hefty fine in court and a driving ban for a week, but his insurance did cover the cost of a lawer as it was a works car and he said had he not had a lawyer would have been much worse.

CC_R
Feb 23, 2012

My mother did it, for exactly the same offence. Drove too far up, was stuck in traffic and had to turn while the lights changed. She explained it, said she was sorry, that she never comitted any other traffic offences and the judge gave her a conditional punishment - so she didn't have to pay the fine.

questionmark
Feb 23, 2012

First you need to answer straight away at the lettre you receved with the fine and say that you contest the fine . Further on , you'll need to go to court It's not necessary to take a lawer but just have to be able to understand some french or flemish and be able to answer.
I agree with questionmark with good behaviour in the past ....

solasi
Feb 24, 2012

Please log in to post an answer

  • Contact
  • Mediakit
  • Terms & Conditions